Cornwall Alliance

For the Stewardship of Creation

  • Home
  • About
    • Listen To Our Podcast “Created to Reign!”
    • Who We Are
    • What We Do
    • What Drives Us
    • Our History in Highlights
    • Cornwall Alliance Statement of Faith
  • Landmark Documents
  • Issues
  • Blog
  • Media
    • Press Releases
  • Shop
    • Books
    • DVDs
  • Contact
    • Challenging “Net-Zero”: Conquering Poverty While Stewarding the Earth in the Age of Climate Change
    • Summer Essay Contest!
    • Request a Talk Show Guest
    • Request Opinion Columns
    • Q&A Form
    • Request A Speaker
  • Donate
  • Get Our Newest Book: Climate and Energy: The Case for Realism

Where the Buffalo Roamed—and Roam Again

by E. Calvin Beisner

August 22, 2016

7154862791_ae6121f59b_k

As a child in a good elementary school in the small town of Owego, New York, in the early 1960s, I learned dozens of old folk songs. Among them was “Home on the Range,” which I, like many of my fellow students, loved to sing, feeling all romantic about life on the range—ridin’ your faithful horse, sleepin’ under the stars, shootin’ rattlesnakes, tamin’ wild horses, herdin’ cattle, and singin’ ’round the campfire. Of course, none of us had ever seen the range, other than in cowboy Westerns, but that didn’t quench our sentimentality.

O give me a home where the buffalo roam,

where the deer and the antelope play,

where seldom is heard a discouraging word,

and the skies are not cloudy all day.

Home, home on the range! …

Elbridge Francis "E.F." Ball, "The Sundance Kid," ca. 1915–1920

Elbridge Francis “E.F.” Ball, “The Sundance Kid,” ca. 1915–1920

We all loved to sing that—I especially because my maternal grandfather had been a cattle rancher in Wyoming and had lived just that life before he was caught in a stampede that broke “practically every bone in his body”—from which he was expected never to recover, though by true grit he did, even learning to walk without a limp though one leg was left three inches shorter than the other. (He also became a marshal nicknamed “Sundance Kid” when he lived in Sundance, Wyoming, where my mother was born.)

I had a particular passion for the buffalo, those lumbering giants of the old American west, even though later, in middle school, fellow students taunted me by calling me “Buffie Bison”—playing on the pronunciation of my last name, BICE-ner, which they figured sounded at least a bit like bison. (Why they thought that should be a taunt I never could understand.)

I was sad that the bison had been hunted nearly to extinction. Like most people, I thought their near disappearance was largely because of what I would later learn to call “the tragedy of the commons”—they were a valuable resource to which nobody had property rights and therefore everybody had an incentive to consume as much as possible as quickly as possible lest it be consumed by somebody else first.

Well, that explanation, however intuitively attractive, isn’t true.

The truth is that because cattle converted grass to meat so much more efficiently than buffalo and could be herded, harvested, and therefore brought to market so much more cheaply, the buffalo—so long as they remained in the massive numbers of the early 1800s (estimated at 30 million at the height and still 10 million by 1870), were a negative economic value. They were more valuable dead and rotting than alive and chewing up grass that otherwise could feed cattle.

My old friend Dr. P.J. Hill summarizes the story here and develops it more fully here. He brings much-needed correction to common perceptions about ecological harm in the old west. And he also explains why, once they became sufficiently rare that they had value as an ecological curiosity and an aesthetic amenity, private investors gained incentive to establish property rights in them. The result? Their numbers have grown from a few hundred to 450,000, of which about 220,000 are in the United States.

Meanwhile, I have the pleasure of actually liking something President Obama has done. He designated the bison the U.S. national mammal back in May.

Dated: August 22, 2016

Tagged With: Bisen, Buffalo, Cattle, Cattle Rancher, Food, Grass, Meat
Filed Under: Animal, Plant & Eco-System Rights, Biodiversity & Endangered Species, Bridging Humanity and the Environment, Environmental Subjects, Food Ethics, Food, Health & Agriculture

About E. Calvin Beisner

Dr. Beisner is Founder and National Spokesman of The Cornwall Alliance; former Associate Professor of Historical Theology & Social Ethics, at Knox Theological Seminary, and of Interdisciplinary Studies, at Covenant College; and author of “Where Garden Meets Wilderness: Evangelical Entry into the Environmental Debate” and “Prospects for Growth: A Biblical View of Population, Resources, and the Future.”

Comments

  1. James Peterson says

    December 3, 2016 at 12:13 pm

    I thought The vanquishing of the buffalo, a systematic slaughter following the civil war, was somehow connected to clearing the West of its warrior aborigines. If one were to,Destroy their food supply, their war making ability would be destroyed. The destruction of the bison laid open millions of acres to be farmed, land to be settled, to be gifted, as well, to the railroads as an asset against which they could borrow the moneys necessary to lay their tracks. The railroad and the bison could never cohabit the same land, could never live in peace with each other. The bison and the West’s Native American were inextricably linked and both had to be vanquished, subdued, placed on reservations, if the West was ever to be settled, and its wealth, hitherto buried in the ground, was to be resurrected

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Listen To Our Podcast


Available to listen on these platforms:

Spotify
Amazon Music
Apple Podcast
Google Podcast
Stitcher

Future Speaking Engagements

June 18-21, 2025–Dallas, TX

Cornwall Alliance will be a host of the Association of Classical Christian Schools’ (ACCS) annual Repairing the Ruins conference in Dallas, TX, and will have an exhibit booth.

Details and registration can be found HERE.

September 19-20–Arlington, VA

Dr Beisner will represent the Cornwall Alliance at the fall meeting of the Philadelphia Society and will have a literature table.

Attendance is for Society members and invited guests only. To inquire about an invitation, email Dr. Cal Beisner: Calvin@cornwallalliance.org.

September 26-27– Lynchburg, VA

Dr. Beisner will be speaking at the Christian Education Initiative Annual Summit, “Advancing Christ’s Kingdom Through Biblical Worldview Education.” 

Details and registration can be found HERE.

Are Science & Religion in Conflict?

Join Our Email List

Select list(s) to subscribe to


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: . You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Recent Stewards Blog Posts

  • The staggering money wasted on Net Zero
  • Climate-obsessives’ Infantile Reading of Polar Ice
  • The Faux Science of Outlawing Fossil Fuels
  • Trump Takes Steps Toward a Nuclear Future
  • GAO Questions Biden’s Offshore Wind Effort, Vindicates Critics

Top 40 Global Warming Blog by Feedspot

Search

Listen to Our Podcast

Available to listen on these platforms:

Spotify
Amazon Music
Apple Podcast
Google Podcast
Stitcher



Copyright © 2025 · Cornwall Alliance · 875 W. Poplar Avenue Suite 23-284, Collierville, TN 38017 · Phone: (423) 500-3009

Designed by Ingenious Geeks & John A. Peck · Log in